The First Year and Early Progress
The first summer was easy! I refreshed existing beds by taking out dead and diseased plants, filled gaps with shrubs to create a layers look, heavily pruned the wisteria and mapped out a plan for the following year. Last year we added trellised and plenty of climbers to create interest, height and inject a bit more colour.
The Big Challenge: Shallow Soil
Then came my plan for digging up a large area of the lawn to create new beds for my cottage garden vision. Under the partial shade of my plum tree we cleared a space approximately 5 x 2m, carefully creating curves, joining to an existing border and moving the old path ready for new planting. But then came the big issue. Just a few inches below the surface, I hit a stubborn mix of poor clay soil, mixed gravel and an old layer of plastic left behind by a previous owner. It quickly became clear that my soil was far shallower than I’d hoped – probably 20-30cm deep at best. I of course had a panic that this would majorly limit what I could plant. My goal was to create an area filled with large plants that had a mature look but I was starting to worry I’d be restricted to throwing down wildflower seeds instead. After a bit of research, I realised that shallow soil doesn’t have to stop you creating the garden you want. It will certainly mean a more particular approach rather than just picking for aesthetics but it can work!
Understanding Shallow Soil
If you’ve found yourself in a similar situation, you’re not alone. Shallow soil is more common than you might think, especially in gardens with a bit of history. Whether it’s caused by rubble, compacted ground, or leftover materials, it can make planting feel like an uphill battle.
In simple terms, shallow soil is exactly what it sounds like, soil that doesn’t go very deep before you hit something solid such as rock or, in some cases, man-made layers. Most plants prefer deeper soil because it allows their roots to spread, access water, and gather nutrients so without that depth, plants desperate to spread their roots can struggle to establish, dry out quickly, or become unstable.
Practical Solutions: Building Up and Improving Soil
One of the most effective solutions with shallow soil is to build upwards rather than downwards. Raised beds are a fantastic option – maybe planned ahead of time before you get to my situation and have already dug up a large area of lawn. By creating a simple frame and filling it with good-quality topsoil and compost, you give plants the depth they need without having to dig out what’s underneath. Even adding a few extra inches can make a noticeable difference.
Improving the soil you already have is another worthwhile step and something I did almost straight away. Adding organic matter such as compost, well-rotted manure, or leaf mould helps improve structure, boosts nutrients, and can balance drainage. Over time, this can make shallow soil far more plant-friendly.
Choosing the Right Plants
Another key part of the solution is choosing plants that naturally cope well with limited soil depth. Some plants are far more adaptable than others and can thrive in conditions that might seem tricky at first glance. Depending on the final look you want to achieve will depend on what you pick but there are a number of options that will work.
Alpine plants are a great choice. These are used to growing in rocky, shallow conditions, so they’re perfectly suited to this kind of environment. Herbs are also excellent choices. Thyme, oregano, and chives are all quite forgiving and do well in shallower, well-drained soil. They’re practical as well as attractive, which is always a bonus.
If you’re after something a bit more striking, lavender and heather are both well suited to these conditions. Lavender, in particular, thrives in sunny spots and adds both colour and fragrance to a garden. For ground cover, creeping plants like creeping thyme can spread across shallow soil, helping to retain moisture while creating a fuller look.
Plant List for a Cottage Garden Look
For a full, overflowing cottage garden look with a mix of textures, colours and heights, this is the list I gathered and began working off:
Campanula – Most low-growing campanulas (like wall or trailing types) are quite adaptable. Moderate spread, forming clumps and looking great along edges as they still fairly small.
Root depth: 15–25 cm
Creeping phlox – classic shallow-soil plant with wide spread suited to gravelly areas.
Root depth: 10–20 cm
Verbena bonariensis – airy, tall stems up to 1.5–2 metres so perfect for the back of a bed to create height and a layered cottage look.
Root depth: 20–30 cm
Foxgloves – Tall flower spikes and very classic cottage garden. Although these are annuals (I personally prefer perennials for lower maintenance) they do self-seed.
Root depth: 25–30 cm
Hollyhock – Similar to foxgloves, these are a staple of a traditional cottage garden and grow to 1-2 metres tall depending on the variety. These do normally require a bit more root space but could adapt especially if the soil quality is good.
Root depth: Can adapt to ~30 cm
Nepeta – Soft, bushy mounds with a long flowering season. These spread nicely to fill gaps so can feel established pretty quickly.
Root depth: 20–30 cm
Lady’s mantle – Rounded, frothy foliage and flowers. This spreads steadily and creates that ‘overflowing’ look.
Root depth: 20–25 cm
Lavender – Essential for that classic cottage garden feel, long-lived and add fragrance.
Root depth: 25–30 cm
Aquilegia – Often overlooked but I personally love it to fill gaps and as it’s more delicate it’s a nice contrast to some of the bulkier shrubs. Can work in gravel or poor soil and has a more natural and wild feel especially as it self-seeds.
Root depth: 20–30 cm
Ongoing Care and Maintenance
The solution isn’t just to plant the correct plants, it’s worth paying attention to watering and maintenance. Shallow soil dries out more quickly, especially in warmer weather, so regular watering is important. Adding a layer of mulch annually such as bark, gravel, or compost can help retain moisture and protect the soil surface.
Final Thoughts
While my original garden plan felt slightly out of reach at first, learning how to work with shallow soil rather than against it has completely changed my approach. With a few adjustments and the right plant choices, it’s entirely possible to create a garden that feels full, colourful, and well established.
If you’re ready to start your journey to a new garden, click here to arrange a relaxed, no-obligation conversation.
Take a look at our case studies for more garden design inspiration.